__The Robert F. Sibert Medal__
The Sibert Award and Honor Awards are presented to the authors of the most distinguished informational children's books published the previous year.
Award Terms:
Poetry and traditional literature (e.g., folktales) are not eligible. There are no other limitations as to the character of the book providing it is an original work. Honor books may be named. They are books that are also truly distinguished. The award is restricted to authors, author/illustrator, co-authors, or author and illustrator named on the title page who are citizens or residents of the United States. The award is restricted to original work first published in the United States. The committee is to consider in its deliberations only books eligible for the award as specified in the terms. The award may be given posthumously.
Award Criteria:
In identifying the most distinguished informational book for children from the preceding year, committee members consider important elements and qualities:
- Excellent, engaging, and distinctive use of language.
- Excellent, engaging, and distinctive visual presentation.
- Appropriate organization and documentation.
- Clear, accurate, and stimulating presentation of facts, concepts, and ideas.
- Appropriate style of presentation for subject and for intended audience.
- Supportive features (index, table of contents, maps, timelines, etc).
- Respectful and of interest to children.
Not every book relies equally on every element. The committee need not find excellence in every element listed above but only in those relevant to the book. The book must be a self-contained entity, not dependent on other media for enjoyment. The Sibert Award is presented to honor distinguished informational books for children. The award is not presented for didactic intent or for popularity.
Things We Found Interesting about the Sibert Award
While reading our books for this award, we noticed a few common factors to their classification as Sibert Honor Books and Medal Winners. Essentially, all of these books can be categorized as informational books. Yet one thing that caught us off guard, was that each book had a story to tell. Each work had a plot and obstacles to overcome. While some of the books on the Sibert list seemed daunting and a bit boring at first, each book eventually became enthralling. We found ourselves becoming engrossed in reading each of them. Some of us read more of the books just for fun! Many of the books can be placed in their own genres, such as autobiography, history, science, and art. The common link between these genres, however, was the historicism behind each piece. Each piece had a true back story, one that helped develop the main characters of each work, and each of the back stories were based on historical fact. Also, one key link between the science based books was that in each one there were diagrams, detailed photos, and charts which made it easier for young readers to understand the material. Because these books were informational each book was filled with definitions, but were not presented like a typical textbook would incorporate them. The writers would say a concept, or a technical term, and then define it within the context of the work. This technique made each book exceptionally easy to read.
While reading each of the award winning books, we found that the award generally showed privilege to those books that shared a theme of overcoming racism. Some examples of this include,
Freedom Riders, Claudette Colvin, When Marian Sang, and We are the Ship. In each of these books we found that the main characters, as well as the overall plot of the story, was to shine light on the obstacles that were to be overcome despite the odds against them. In
Freedom Riders, part of the overwhelming power of the story was the viewpoints of a black man and a white man during the civil rights movement. Not only was this a time turmoil for blacks, but the book also showed the trials faced by those whites who were against the segregation of public facilities. In
When Marian Sang,the biggest obstacle, not only for Marian, but for most African Americans in the early 1930s was getting others to judge their character and not the color of their skin. Standing in front of the Abraham Lincoln memorial singing "America" , Marian overcame racism and showed others that they can too. In
We are the Ship, the only people who were able to play professional baseball were white men. African Americans decided to create a league of their own and start to travel places. The conditions of their travel was horrible. They weren't allowed to eat in restaurants, sleep in hotels, and the buses were cramped and uncomfortable. Although they face racism constantly, they got to play baseball which was the most important thing to them.
Another theme that we found while reading each of the award and honor books, were they gave privilege to activism. Books such as
Pedro and Me,
The Voice That Challenged a Nation,and
The Life and Death of Adolf Hitler exemplified this theme. In each of these books we found that the main objective of each character, was to spread a message by getting people involved in their cause. In
Pedro and Me, Pedro becomes an activist for the HIV cause by giving information on how to prevent contracting this disease and how to treat those living with HIV. With the help from his Real World roomates they were able to shatter the myths and fears of society. Also, in
The Voice That Challenged a Nation, Marian Anderson fights through the struggle of being an African American woman trying to make it as a singer. During this time Civil Rights was being fought heavily throughout our nation and Marian Anderson helped to spread the message that it's okay to be African American and that she should have the same rights as any other American. Although known for his reign of terror, Adolf Hitler too was an activist. He spent his lifetime getting others to agree and support his viewpoint of creating the perfect race.
The Life and Death of Adolf Hitler exemplifies the steps Adolf Hitler took to develop his own ideas and to get his country active in his vision.
The last theme our books share are ground breaking historical events. These events can be new inventions or events that change the course of history. Some examples include,
Vincent Van Gogh, We are the Ship, The Longitude Prize, and Claudette Colvin. In
Vincent Van Gogh, as a painter, he used color to express emotion and mood. Other artists during that time were making realistic paintings and colors. Vincents technique and style was unheard of, which led to alot of people not liking his work. In
We are the Ship, Jackie Robinson signed with the Brooklyn Dodgers in 1945 and was the first African American to play professional baseball. Jackie Robinson faced racism head on and didn't fight back. If he did, the chances of other African Americans to play baseball would have never happened. In
The Longitude Prize the British Parliament offered a prize of 20,000 pounds to the person who could invent a simple device to determine longitude while out at sea. Fifty years after the prize was offered, there were two people who invented devices. In the end, the self-educated man named John Harrison won the prize for the seagoing clock that he invented.
Claudette Colvin also took part in historical events, although not known as widely as Rosa Park's stand against bus segregation, Colvin too refused the segregation that eventually would be a landmark event in the start of the Civil Rights movement.
Award Winning and Nominated Books
My Season with Penguins
By Sophie Webb
2001 Honor Book
My season with Penguins is a compilation of an artists journey. Sophie Webb travels to the cold climate plain of Antartica. Throughout her two-month stay she observes, records and draws her new found animal friends.
The Brooklyn Bridge
By Lynn Curlee
2002 Honor Book
Brooklyn Bridge provides detailed information on the process of how the Brooklyn Bridge was built. A fourteen-year project now stands as on of the most popular world landmarks.
Hole in My Life
By Jack Gantos
2003 Honor Book
After being imprisoned at a young age, Jack Gantos re-tells his story of how he turned his life around and became the man he is today.
To Dance: A Ballerina's Graphic Novel
By Siena Cherson Siegel
2007 Honor Book
This is a story of Siena Siegel, her dream of becoming a prima ballerina, and how she overcame her obstacles to make her dream a reality.
What to Do About Alice
By Barbra Kerley
2009 Medal Winner
This is an entertaining bibliography about Alice, President Theodore Rooesevelts daughter and their chaotic life in the WHite House.
Team Moon: How 400,000 People Landed Apollo 11 on the Moon
By Catherine Thimmesh
2007 Medal Winner
This is an in depth behind the scenes look into the first Apollo moon landing, from the first ideas to the final landing.
Sequoyah
By James Rumford
2005 Honor Book
In 1958 a crippled Sequoyah struggles to create the Cherokee writing system.
The Tarantula Scientist
By Sy Montogomery
2005 Honor Book
This is a documentary of Sam Marshall's research and findings, dealing with the tarantula.
An American Plague: The True and Terrifying Story of the Yellow Fever Epidemic of 1793
By Jim Murphy
2004 Medal Winner
Yellow Fever epidemic in 1793 was a deadly outbreak of influenza in Philadelphia that killed thousands of people, and forced President Washington to flee the city in its time of need.
Six Days in October: The Stock Market Crash of 1929
By Karen Blumenthal
2003 Honor Book
A compilation of stories from people who seen the effects of Black Tuesday and the Crash of '29.
Black Potatoes: The Story of the Great Irish Famine, 1845-1850
By Susan Campbell Bartoletti
2002 Medal Winner
A historical account of the mid-19th century mystery that rendered the staple diet of the Irish inedible, killing one million and sending two million refugees abroad.
Hitler Youth: Growing up in Hitler's Shadow
By Susan Campbell Bartoletti
2006 Honor Book
The recounting of growing up in Nazi-Germany, and the excitement and fury surrounding the notorious Hitler Youth. It explores the memories of those who lived during the Third Reich's rise to power and its ultimate demise.
Surviving Hitler: A Boy in the Nazi Death Camps
By Andrea Warren
2002 Honor Book
Jack recounts surviving Hitler's rise to power and the horrible atrocities of the death camps.
Secrets of a Civil War Submarine: Solving the Mysteries of the H.L. Hunley
By Sally M. Walker
2008 Medal Winner
A scientific and historic exploration of the Civil War submarine H.L. Hunley, the first sub to destroy an enemy ship, and also the search and reclamation of the Hunley after its discovery in Charleston Bay in 1995.
I Face The Wind
By Vicki Cobb
2004 Honor Book
This book introduces the wind, how it works and functions, through a series of hands-on activities it teaches how to understand something you cannot see.
The Wall: Growing Up behind the Iron Curtain
by Peter Sís
2008 Medal Winner
A young Czechoslovakian boy must creatively express himself in order to deal with the chaos of the Cold war.
Pedro and Me: Friendship, Loss and What I Learned
By Judd Winick
2001 Honor Book
Pedro and Me is a tale about a young man's journey to bring health awareness to young people.
Blizzard! The Storm That Changed America
By Jim Murphy
2001 Honor Book
A strong storm hits the Northeastern States of the U.S. unexpectedly in the late 1800's.
The Longitude Prize
By Joan Dash
2001 Honor Book
A prize is offered for a simple and practical device that could determine longitude to the sailors in the early 1700's.
Sir Walter Ralegh and the Quest for El Dorado
By Marc Aronson
2001 Medal Winner
This award winning book covers Sir Walter Ralegh's biography and his quest to find the mythological city of El Dorado.
Vincent Van Gogh: Portrait of an Artist
By Jan Greenberg and Sandra Jordan
2002 Honor Book
Vincent Van Gogh had a hard time living up to his families expectations. By being an outcast, it gave him the drive and passion to paint masterpieces
When Marian Sang
By Pam Muñoz
2003 Honor Book
Marian must break down the walls of racism by using, the only weapon she has, her voice.
Action Jackson
By Jan Greenberg and Sandra Jordan
2003 Honor Book
Jackson Pollock changed the way an artist approached a canvas.
Walt Whitman: Words for America
By Barbara Kerley
2005 Honor Book
Walt Whitman, a proud American writer, does his part to honor the voice of America and its president, Abraham LIncoln, during the Civil War and time immediately following.
The Voice That Challenged a Nation: Marian Anderson and the Struggle for Equal Rights
By Russel Freedman
2005 Medal Winner
Marian Anderson, an African American woman, explains in this documentary the hardships she faced while acheiving her goal to become a professional singer.
Quest for the Tree Kangaroo: An Expedition to the Cloud Forest of New Guinea
By Sy Montgomery
2007 Honor Book
Scientist Lisa Dabek studies the rare Matschie's tree kangaroo in the tall trees of the Papua New Guinea rainforest.
Freedom Riders: John Lewis and Jim Zwerg on the Front Lines of the Civil Rights Movement</em
By Ann Bausum
2007 Honor Book
John Lewis and Jim Zwerg, a black and white man, make a stand against racism during the 1960's civil rights movement.
Spiders
By Nic Bishop
2008 Honor Book
An interesting picture and fact filled book about the different types of spiders.
Lightship
By Brian Floca
2008 Honor Book
A journey through the ships that guide the way on the ocean for larger ships is explained in this factual, yet picturual book.
Bodies from the Ice: Melting Glaciers and the Recovery of the Past
By James M. Deem
2009 Honor Book
The worlds glaciers have been rapidly melting. As the glaciers are forming slushy ice water, hidden treasures from the past are being revealed.
We Are the Ship: The Story of Negro League Baseball
By Kadir Nelson
2009 Medal Winner
Segregation forced African Americans to play baseball in a separate league. With self control and determination, Jackie Robinson gave African Americans a chance to finally be able to play professional baseball.
Almost Astronauts: 13 Women Who Dared to Dream
By Tanya Lee Stone
2010 Medal Winner
13 women dreamed to fly to the moon and now as they watched one of their own shooting into space they realized their dream was now a reality.
The Day-Glo Brothers: The True Story of Bob and Joe Switzer's Bright Ideas and Brand New Colors
By Chris Barton
2010 Honor Book
Joe Switzer wanted to make his magic act better. With the help of his brother Bob, they created a fluorescent paint that is used on signs and store windows.
Moonshot: The Flight of Apollo 11
By Brian Floca
2010 Honor Book
Apollo 13 was an important space shuttle launch. In this exciting book, the reader will encounter a first hand look into the spacecrafts flight.
Claudette Colvin: Twice Toward Justice
By Phillip Hoose
2010 Honor Book
Claudette Colvin, a black teen during the civil rights movement, must face the racial prejudice of her time and overcome obstacles to stand up for what she believes in.
The Life and Death of Adolf Hitler
By James Cross Giblin
2003 Medal Winner
A historical view of the life surrounding Adolf Hitler and the vivid events that shaped the man known today for his violent actions preceding World War II.